Edited by Roderick
P. Murphy, President
Degreasing Devices Co.
Southbridge, MA (5/00)
This is a short synopsis (Below this synopsis is a
more detailed version.) of what a vapor degreaser (VD) is, the various
types of VDs and what solvents are used in VDs. There are two types of
VDs. One is a vapor immersion unit which usually has two solvent-filled
sumps (the boil sump and the cold sump which is filled with clean, distilled
condensate solvent and is often used for rinsing). An ultrasonics-equipped
degreaser is a version of a vapor immersion type degreaser. The other
type of degreaser is a vapor/spray unit in which the solvent is boiled
in the very bottom of a one-sump degreaser. There is a perforated metal
stand just above the boiling solvent. A metal basket filled with dirty
parts is usually placed on this stand. The basket or parts are not immersed
in solvent. Instead the vapor made by the boiling solvent encompasses
the parts completely and removes the oils and soils. The oils and soils,
now diluted into the condensing liquid, will drip back into the boiling
solvent below. There is a manual spray wand, which is sprayed under the
cooling coils, directly on hard-to-remove soil.
Near the top of the either type of degreaser is a set of cooling coils,
that catches the vapor before it escapes from the unit. It cools and condenses
it back to its liquid form and flows it back to a clean condensate tank
and finally it goes back to the boil sump or the rinse tank. Since oil
and grease boil at a higher temperature than for chlorinated solvents,
the vapor caused by the now oil mixed solvent, only vaporizes the clean
chlorinated solvent not the dirty oil, if the temperature settings are
correctly set. Therefore only clean vapor is used to clean parts.
There are 3 standard chlorinated degreaser type solvents - trichloroethylene(TCE),
methylene chloride and perchloroethylene (perc). There are other new VD
solvents which are more expensive but have certain characteristics which
require their use in some cleaning situations. By the way, chlorinated
solvents (and the newer vapor degreaser solvents) have no flash point
so they are not flammable. Non vapor degreasing solvents like acetone,
xylene, methyl ethyl ketone, alcohols, etc. should not be used in heated
tanks that are not explosion proof like VDs. All are flammable.
Editor's note. I believe, in spite of the somewhat bad and
unjustified environmental reputation that vapor degreasers have acquired
in the late 80s and early 90s, there is no better method of cleaning metal
(and other) parts of oil, grease, wax, flux, etc. With updated equipment
and careful operation, there should be no environmental damage done. My
company also sells aqueous washers and other types of parts washers but
I am sold on vapor degreasing. Rod Murphy 4/11/00
Nothing written or implied in this booklet should be considered
as recommendations or in any way are the writers or editors of this booklet
liable for any damages.
Some Ideas on Basic Vapor Degreaser Use
The minimum that equipment for vapor degreasing must
provide is: adequate space for effective cleaning; allowing sufficient
contact with the solvent (vapor and/or liquid) to remove soils, and capability
to recycle the solvent for extended use.
The design of vapor degreasing equipment is determined
by the size, shape, and specific heat of the parts to be cleaned; volume
and rate of production; and the type and amount of soils to be removed.
These considerations in turn influence the cleaning cycle selected and
the method of moving parts through the cycle. Federal, state, and local
emissions and other regulations are a further influence, as is on-site
availability and economy of a heating source.
Basic Degreaser Design
VDs vary in size and type from small, manually operated machines to automated,
conveyorized systems. The simplest VD is a rectangular tank with a sump
of boiling solvent in the bottom. The cleaning space, or vapor zone, is
just above the boiling solvent.
To confine solvent vapor to the tank and prevent vapor loss to the atmosphere,
a refrigerant or water cooled external jacket or internal coils are located
above the vapor zone. Clean vapor condensate is collected in a trough,
passed through a water separator to remove excess moisture, and returned
to the boiling sump. Degreasers commonly are designed with larger condensers
than actually required, in order to minimize solvent loss and prevent
vapor contamination of the air in the work area.
Buying a Vapor Degreaser
The number of vapor degreaser manufacturers has waxed and waned in this
new era of mergers, federal and regional emissions and other pertinent
regulations. Some of the older well known names, BRANSON, BARON BLAKESLEE,
FINISHING EQUIPMENT remain in the business; some with different ownership.
Other firms discontinued making VDs; TALLY, CREST. And some have gone
out of the business; LENAPE and DELTA. There are also a few new VD manufacturers.
And there are some import manufacturers like FLONIC.
In the USA there are a few wholesale dealers specializing in used vapor
degreasers. Such dealers can provide late model, good condition VDs with
EPA required retrofits at half the cost of a new degreaser or less. Some
specialty dealers are veterans in the business and can provide helpful
advice also.
Freeboard Function and Design
The sides of the VD tank extend above the condenser (cooling coils), and
this area is called freeboard. Its purpose is to shield the vapor zone
from air currents that could cause turbulence and resultant vapor loss.
Since excessive solvent vapor loss also contributes to atmospheric contamination,
freeboard height is subject to federal and state and regional regulations;
EPA requires that the freeboard height be at least the same as the width
of the tank (narrowest dimension) or "100% freeboard".
Storage Tank
Most degreasers have a separate storage tank for clean, distilled solvent,
This provides a supply of contaminant-free solvent for immersion degreasing
or spraying.
Sizing the Equipment
Equipment sizing for an open-tank degreaser represents a balance between
process requirements and solvent conservation. There must be sufficient
working area in the vapor zone to avoid a piston action that will pump
solvent vapors out of the machine as work is immersed and removed. An
open-tank degreaser requires at least 50 percent greater working area
than the dimensions of the largest workload. Beyond satisfying this requirement,
tank size should be kept to a minimum to avoid excessive vapor loss through
evaporation.
To further control vapor loss, environmental regulations as well as economic
considerations dictate a freeboard design with an adequate ratio of freeboard
height to tank width, federal and state regulations require that the freeboard
height be at least equal to the width of the tank, i.e.100% freeboard.
In 1994 the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) promulgated a complicated
set of related regulations called NESHAPS.
Heat Requirements
Heat input requirements for vapor degreasing are determined by the weight
and specific heat of the work (which has to be heated to the solvent boiling
point), radiation losses from the tank walls, solvent distillation, and
the solvent used.
Heating the Work
The number of BTUs required hourly to maintain the solvent at boiling
temperature can be calculated by multiplying the pounds/hour of work to
be cleaned by the specific heat of the metal and the difference between
ambient temperature and the boiling point of the solvent in degrees Fahrenheit.
A safety factor of 50 percent is usually added.
For large workloads, added heating coils can be provided to minimize temperature
swings. It is important to maintain a constant vapor level to minimize
vapor loss; therefore sufficient heat input should be available to raise
the workload surface temperature to the vapor temperature as quickly as
possible.
Radiation Losses
If radiation losses from bare tank walls become excessive, it can be reduced
by insulating the tank walls. Radiation losses will vary with the boiling
point of the solvent. High heat perc degreasers should be insulated on
the outside for operator safety and to reduce radiation loss.
Heating for Solvent Distillation
The heat required to produce clean distillate for spraying or multiple
immersion chambers should be included in determining total heat input
required.
Heat Sources
Heat input for vapor degreasing can be supplied by electricity, steam,
and gas or by a heat pump. Most systems recently manufactured use electricity.
Electricity
Immersion heaters with a heat density of about 20 watts/sq. in. are generally
used in electric heating installations. It is important that the liquid
solvent level be kept above the immersion heater, since an exposed heating
element will elevate surface temperature and result in solvent decomposition
and burnout of the heating element. A low-liquid-level shutoff will provide
warning.
Steam
Immersed steam coils are generally used to supply heat to the solvent;
other methods include plate coils or steam-jacketed tank bottoms. Steam
pressures required to achieve the boiling point for clean solvent range
from 5-15 psig for TCE and 50-65 psig for perc. As the contamination level
of the solvent increases, its boiling temperature increases accordingly,
as does the steam pressure required to maintain the same rate of distillation.
Hot Water
Pressurized hot water pumped through immersion coils is another heat source
for VDs. Water temperatures and pressures commonly used are 250°-300°
F (121°-1490° C) at 25-70 psig for trichlorethylene, and 300°-325° F (149°-1630°
C) at 70-105 psig for perc.
Gas
Gas heating is less commonly used for vapor degreasing tanks. Immersion
coils are employed, and fuel input is generally sized at twice that required
for steam to allow for combustion inefficiency and flue stack losses.
Operating and Heat Safety Controls
In addition to operating controls specific to the heating system selected,
certain safety controls are common to all heating methods. A coolant flow
switch and temperature control are required to shut off the heat source
if coolant flow is insufficient. A sump thermostat should be set to cut
off heat supply if the sump temperature exceeds recommended maximum for
the solvent used. Further protection against inadequate cooling is provided
by a vapor thermostat, discussed under Vapor Control. All shutoff controls
should require manual resetting. See "Sizing the equipment"
above for information on EPA regulations (NESHAPS) requiring these safety
controls plus some other things.
Heat Safety Controls
Steam: A pressure regulator is required that is suitable for the solvent
used. A pressure gauge and relief valve should be installed on the low-pressure
side. Steam traps should be provided to receive condensate from the steam
coils and return it to the boiler.
Gas: Automatic pilot protection should be provided to shut off all gas
within 45 seconds of pilot failure. Dissolved oil and grease raise the
boiling point of the solvent, and this temperature rise should be limited
by a thermostat. Thermostatic protection against low liquid level, which
might expose the gas immersion coil, also is required. Open flame gas
heated degreasers could be dangerous if exposed to chlorinated solvent
vapor.
Electric: A low-liquid-level device, either thermostatic or of the mechanical
float type, is required to prevent solvent decomposition due to exposed
heating elements.
Warning
An exposed gas or electric heating element will result in excessive surface
temperature of the heating element, with consequent solvent decomposition
and the formation of toxic gases. The reaction also can result in an acid
degreaser and an attendant danger of fire. To insure a minimum level of
solvent, a low liquid level shutoff should be used.
Sump Thermostat
A sump thermostat set to the recommended limit for the solvent used should
be coupled to a shutoff valve with manual reset. Recommended sump thermostat
settings are for methylene chloride; 195° F (91° C) for TCE and 260° F
(127° C) for perc.
Vapor Control
Control of the vapor level is the key to successful degreaser operation.
Vapor control is accomplished by the flow of cooling water through coils
inside the tank or through a jacket around the outside of the tank.
Cooling Coils
Cooling coils are positioned to control the vapor level, allowing clearance
below the work and a vapor layer above the work. Cooling refrigerant or
water temperature above the vapor line should be higher than the dew point
of the surrounding air to avoid condensation of atmospheric moisture.
This can be helped by directing refrigerant or water flow through the
cooling coil from the bottom to the top.
Waterjacket
In addition to or instead of cooling coils, a cooling jacket around the
outside perimeter of the degreaser tank can be used to coot the wall below
the freeboard and condense the solvent.
Vapor Thermostat
Should the vapor level rise above the cooling coils, this sensor will
respond to the temperature of the vapor and shut off the heat source.
The thermostat should require manual resetting. Typical settings are methylene
chloride; 160° F (71° C) for TCE and 180° F (820° C) for perc. Required
by NESHAPS.
Water Separation
Water contamination of the solvent may originate from condensation of
atmospheric moisture, from the surfaces of parts being cleaned, or from
leakage of condenser water or steam lines.
Caution
Excess water in a chlorinated solvent can cause corrosion of parts and
equipment. In particular, 1,1,1 trichloroethane is subject to hydrolysis
in the presence of excessive water, resulting in the formation of acidic
materials. The acidic solvent is corrosive and may cause equipment damage.
To avoid this, guidelines for the design and operation of a water separator
should be carefully followed.
Water in the solvent is usually evidenced by spots appearing on metal
being cleaned. These may be rust-colored if some corrosion has already
occurred. After the solvent evaporates, spots may be visible on the cleaned
work. Another indication of excess water is the formation of a dense white
fog in the vapor zone, called ghosting. The density of the cloud varies
directly with water concentration. A properly designed water separator
located on the condensate return line will keep solvent moisture content
at a low level. Water-contaminated solvent enters the separator through
a pipe below the liquid level. Above, the solvent water interface, water
flows out. Solvent, since it is heavier than water, is drawn off through
a pipe below the interface. Since the separation is accomplished by gravitational
settling of vie heavier solvent, the separator should be designed to provide
adequate retention time. A minimum retention time of five minutes is recommended
for chlorinated solvents. In addition, a deep tank is more efficient than
a shallow design because it minimizes the area of the solvent-water interface.
Since water is not as soluble in methylene chloride, perc or TCE, the
water separator for methylene chloride, perc or TCE may be somewhat smaller.
Separation is further improved by lowering the temperature of the condensate
in a heat exchanger either before it enters the water separator or in
the separator. Water separators operate most efficiently when the solvent
temperature is below 100° F (38° C) for TCE and perc.
Construction Materials
While stainless steel is the preferred material of construction for degreaser
tanks, resin-coated mild steel is satisfactory. Metal accessories preferably
should be stainless steel, brass or bronze. Aluminum or magnesium should
not be used as materials of construction. Zinc-plated or galvanized steel
is not suitable for use with chlorinated solvent.
Caution
Do not use aluminum as a construction material. Chlorinated solvents may
react with aluminum when in constant contact, resulting in solvent decomposition
and consequent equipment damage from the acidic products of decomposition.
Warning
In a closed system, methylene chloride may react with aluminum components
and decompose. The resultant generation of heat, pressure and explosive
gases may rupture the equipment with explosive-like force, causing injury
to nearby personnel. Do not use aluminum piping, pumps or other components.
Materials Handling
Vapor degreasing, is adaptable to a wide range of part sizes and production
requirements, from large parts lowered by hoist to batch cleaning in racks
or baskets to high volume automated installations.
Manual Operation
Large, heavy parts, and assemblies are commonly handled by hoists, which
should be limited to a maximum vertical travel of 11 ft/min. (Required
by NESHAPS) to avoid vapor disturbance. Part size must also be considered
in relation to tank area, with sufficient clearance to avoid a piston
action as the part is lowered and raised. The part area should not exceed
50 percent of the tank area.
Batch production is handled in racks or baskets, with the same caution
about overall basket size to avoid pumping. Since the rack or basket must
be heated along with the work, weight should be kept to a minimum.
Automated Systems
Monorail conveyors are particularly suited to high-volume applications
where parts can be suspended from hooks or hangers. Vertical travel should
be restricted to a maximum speed of 11 ft/minute. The system should be
designed so that the conveyor travels above the vapor zone; automatic
lubrication should be provided as alternative.
Crossrod conveyors are used to degrease small parts in baskets, which
can he designed to rotate to facilitate drainage. The crossrod conveyor
incorporates two parallel strands of chain connected at intervals by rods,
from which the baskets are suspended.
Ferris wheel or Carousel. As the name implies, this design rotates the
work in a number of baskets attached to a wheel-like assembly. The design
is enclosed except at the operator station where work is loaded and unloaded.
Variations of immersion and spray can be included in the cleaning cycle,
as well as rotation of the baskets.
Vibra conveyor: This high-capacity design is particularly effective in
cleaning small metal parts such as fasteners, screw machine products and
small die castings. A combination of solvent action and vibration is responsible
for its effectiveness in cleaning hard-to-remove solids. The parts are
directed to the bottom of a spiral elevator which is actuated by a vibrator
drive. The vibrating action moves the parts upward along the spiral through
solvent and vapors where soil is flushed away and the parts dried.
Elevator conveyors are batch-type, and incorporate a platform - usually
made of open rollers - to lower and raise the work. The design can be
adapted to provide closed operation. Care should be taken to provide sufficient
clearance between the elevator platform and the tank walls to avoid pumping.
Degreaser Installation
Location of a VD usually is dictated by its position in the production
sequence, but available space or environmental problems within the plant
may influence this decision. Consideration also should be given to proximity
of other processes, such as paint finishing where solvent vapors could
have an effect on the work.
Space Requirements
Because of the short cycle time involved in vapor degreasing and the compact
design of the equipment, VDs require a minimum of space. Ceiling height
ordinarily is not a problem. Where parts with long vertical dimensions
must be cleaned and ceiling height is a restriction, the degreaser can
be installed in a pit.
Clearance
There should be sufficient clearance around the machine to allow access
to cleanout doors and to permit removal of heating elements.
Elevation
For a manually operated, open top degreaser, the top of the tank should
be 48" above floor level or the operating platform; or a railing
provided at this level. The 48"inch height is considered adequate
to protect against accidental falls and to provide a safe breathing zone.
Locating a Degreaser in a Pit
Degreasers installed in pits require clearance similar to those at floor
level for access and maintenance. A 48"inch high rail should surround
the pit, and the open tank area covered by grating.
Warning
Solvent vapors are heavier than air, and presents a hazard in a pit or
other low-lying area. Exposure to high concentrations of chlorinated solvent
vapors causes depression of the central nervous system, which can result
in unconsciousness or death. Safe entry procedures must be followed if
it becomes necessary to enter a pit where high concentrations of solvent
vapor may be present.
Drafts
Until EPA's NESHAPS, normal air circulation was considered beneficial
in dissipating the small quantities of solvent vapor usually encountered
in degreaser operation. Accordingly, former recommendations for degreaser
location was where there is sufficient ventilation to maintain vapor concentration
in the air below accepted Time-Weighted Average (TWA) values. Since the
1994's NESHAPS, required design of VDs has been tightened so that solvent
emissions should be minimum. However, cross-drafts can scoop solvent vapors
from the degreaser, and cause excessive vapor loss. The degreaser should
not be located where it can be affected by drafts from windows, doors,
fans, unit heaters, ventilators, or adjacent spray booths. If necessary,
the tank should be enclosed with walls.
Avoid open flames and hot surfaces!
Caution
Do not install a VD near gas heated ovens, space heaters, open flames
or hot surfaces above 750° F (399° F); or near welding or heat treating
operations. Solvent vapors may decompose upon contact with hot surfaces
or open flames, producing acidic products which can cause corrosion of
surrounding structures.
Warning !
Arc welding should not be attempted near VD. Ultraviolet radiation from
the arc welding may cause decomposition of solvent vapors and the generation
of a strong disageeable odor together with the localized formation of
toxic gases, These gases could cause personal injury to the welder.
Gas-heated Degreasers
Gas-heated degreasers must not be located in a room where the general
mechanical exhaust system produces a negative pressure unless a powered
exhaust device is provided to remove all products of combustion. Open
flame gas jets are a possible danger when exposed to chlorinated solvent
vapors.
Degreaser Operation
Before attempting startup or operation of vapor degreasing equipment,
an operator should be thoroughly familiar with the operation, control
and maintenance of that particular machine. The manufacturer's operating
instructions should form a part of his training, and the operating instructions
should be permanently positioned in a conspicuous location on the machine.
The operator should be equally familiar with recommended safety practices
as well as the hazards related to the solvent being used. Operating temperatures
and pressures and thermostat settings for VDs and stills are available
from degreaser manufacturers, used equipment dealers and chemical distributors.
Degreaser Startup
The following general procedure is recommended when starting the VD:
- Turn on condensing water, and check to make
sure that it is flowing properly.
- Turn on self-contained, refrigerated units
and the chiller goes on before anything else automatically.
- Actuate all control devices and check periodically
to insure proper operation. This includes the automatic heat shutoff
thermostat above the condensing zone, maximum surface temperature controls
on heating elements, and maximum solvent temperature control in cleaning
compartments. Usually all these safety controls go on when the main
switch is thrown.
- Add solvent in all compartments as necessary.
- Check to make sure that degreaser covers,
which should have been in place during idle period, remain so during
startup.
- Turn on heat supply and, if degreaser is
steam-heated, check settings to conform with those recommended for the
solvent used. Electrically heated units go on with main switch.
- As degreaser reaches operating temperature,
adjust heat so that upper level of vapor zone is at the midpoint of
the condenser coils. Maximum operating efficiency and minimum solvent
loss are obtained when vapor generation is balanced by condensation
from the work load and condensing coils.
- When the vapor zone has reached the condenser
coils, check to insure that condensed solvent is flowing to the water
separator, and through it to the proper degreaser compartments. The
ideal is when the solvent is dripping heavily from the cooling coils
back into the underneath trough.
- Check all thermometers and gauges to insure
that readings are in the proper operating range.
- Start cleaning cycle.
- Check water flow through condenser, and
cooling water temperature, which should be 90°-120° F (32°-49° C) at
the discharge outlet of the water coils. This range will provide effective
cooling and minimize atmospheric condensation. Refrigerated units have
settings (e.g.TCE at approx. 50°F.).
Degreaser Operation
Given a specific heat input, a degreaser will vaporize solvent at a given
volume and rate, and this establishes the number of pounds per hour of
work that can be cleaned effectively. Exceeding the capacity of the degreaser
will cause fluctuations in the vapor level, which increase solvent consumption
and may result in poor cleaning and longer cleaning cycles.
Following are some guidelines for efficient VD operation:
Work positioning
Parts should be racked so that there is complete contact with the solvent
throughout the cleaning cycle. and thorough draining in each phase. Solvent
trapped in pockets or recesses will result in excessive solvent dragout,
which increases cleaning costs, and in atmospheric contamination. Used
condensate should not drip from one part to another.
Entry and removal rate
To avoid vapor disturbance and consequent solvent loss and atmospheric
contamination, the maximum vertical. travel rate for entry and removal
of work is 11 ft/minute. Required by NESHAPS.
Vapor contact time
The workload should be kept in the vapor zone until its temperature reaches
that of the surrounding vapor and condensation ceases. If removed earlier,
work may not be fully cleaned; and if drying is not complete there is
a consequent loss of solvent.
Work transfer and spraying with the vapor zone
Transfer of work between compartments of the degreaser, and work spraying
should be done below the vapor level to minimize vapor disturbance. Spraying
should be done as low as possible in the vapor zone and in such a manner
that it does not deflect solvent out of the degreaser. Local or state
regulations may require a spray control-switch to shut off the spray pump
if there is an excessive drop in the vapor level. The spray should be
clean distillate or only lightly contaminated. Maintaining the temperature
of the solvent below its boiling point will lower the surface temperature
of the work, and allow the pure vapor in the final cleaning cycle to condense
on and rinse the work.
Solvent contamination level
The solvent contamination level in the degreaser sump should never be allowed
to exceed 25% and should be maintained below this level. 15% contamination
is an even better Preventive Maintenance target to change solvent.
A VD delivers its greatest output and economy when the solvent is clean,
because the effectiveness of the process depends on the ability of the unit
to provide a constant supply of clean solvent vapor. As contamnination increases
cleaning efficiency is reduced.
Excessive solvent contamination will lead to solvent breakdown, insufficient
vapor generation, sludge formation and the baking of sludge on the tank
bottom and heating element. In addition, the boiling temperature of the
oil-solvent mixture rises to a level where it reduces cleaning effectiveness.
Maximum recommended sump temperatures are approximately 193° F (89° C) for
TCE, and 256° F (124° C) for perc.
Water contamination
Sources of water entry into a degreaser should be identified and eliminated
so far as possible to avoid equipment corrosion, spotting of work, and increased
solvent consumption. For a more detailed discussion of moisture removal,
see Water Separation.
Adding solvent to the degreaser
When solvent is added to the degreaser, care should be taken to avoid agitating
the vapor zone. Pumping the solvent into the degreaser, rather than pouring
directly from drums, will minimize disturbance, Makeup solvent ordinarily
is added to the clean rinse compartments or the condensate tank.
Shutting down the degreaser
When not in production, degreasers normally are shut down for economy. Some
low boil solvents may evaporate without on demand refrigeration. The following
steps are a guideline:
- Stop degreaser operation and remove work.
- Shut off heat supply.
- Allow vapor level to drop below condenser area.
- Shut down water supply to condenser.
- Turn off control devices and auxiliary equipment.
- Cover open-tank degreasers.
Caution !
Do not mix different chlorinated solvents or add one solvent to another
without technical assistance, as this may result in an adverse reaction.
Above certain concentrations, 1,1,1-trichloroethane can trigger decomposition
in TCE and cause an acid formation, if added to perc. Mixing small amounts
of TCE in perc also can result in acid formation.
Caution !
Do not allow aluminum parts to remain immersed overnight or for long periods
in chlorinated solvent. This may cause solvent decomposition, resulting
in the formation of corrosive acids and consequent equipment damage. This
is called stacking corrosion.
Solvent Recycling & Conservation
Conservation efforts are directed at minimizing solvent vapor loss; solvent
reclamation lowers operating costs by providing maximum utilization of
the solvent through the higher cleaning efficiency obtainable with clean
solvent.
Solvent Conservation
Solvent conservation prevents the unnecessary loss of solvent vapor to
the atmosphere. Conservation is important economically in reducing solvent
consumption; it is equally important in minimizing air contamination and
worker exposure to solvent vapors.
In addition to good work practices, which are discussed in the section
How to Minimize Vapor Degreasing Costs, several devices can be installed
easily on VD to minimize solvent vapor loss to the atmosphere. Some of
these may be required by state and local regulations under EPA guidelines.
Tank Covers
Flexible or rigid covers should be placed over open-tank degreasers during
any periods that the degreaser is not in use. Covers can be manually or
power-operated. EPA now requires sliding covers rather than pull-up type
covers.
Refrigerated Freeboard Coils
Located around the inside perimeter of the degreaser tank above the condenser,
refrigerated coils create a cold air inversion blanket which helps to
confine the vapors to the condenser area. The coils are supplied from
an external refrigeration unit. Since the refrigerated coils will condense
or freeze atmospheric moisture, a drain trough should be located under
the coils, leading to a water separator with sufficient capacity to handle
the additional water.
Activated Carbon Adsorbers
This method employs a lip exhaust to collect vapor-laden air from the
degreaser. The vapor-air mixture passes through an activated carbon bed,
which traps the solvent. The solvent is recovered by steaming the bed,
then condensing the solvent and steam. A water separator recovers the
solvent, which is then directed to a storage tank.
Solvents may lose a substantial amount of stabilizer with carbon adsorption.
Adsorbers for TCE, methylene chloride or perc should be made of stainless
steel.
Solvent Reclamation
Solvent reclamation offers substantial savings in operating costs by significantly
extending the life of the solvent. The solvent is reclaimed by distillation
and can be accomplished internally, using the degreaser as, the still;
or on a continuous basis in a separate recovery still. Oil, grease and
dirt are separated from the solvent as it is distilled. The pure solvent
vapor is condensed, passed through a water separator, and is ready for
reuse.
Except for relatively low-volume production, internal distillation may
not be suitable because it involves taking the degreaser out of service
during the distillation procedure. In addition, the distillation leaves
a heavy concentration of sludge in the bottom of the degreaser. A dedicated
still, properly installed will be more efficient (possibly 20% better)
than the working degreaser. Also a still is used more often and the still
bottom sludge doesn't build up and usually a still drain is a convenient
waist-high instead a degreaser's toe-high drain. See External Distillation
below.
Warning !
As previously stated, exposure of the heating element during distillation
will result in excessive surface temperature of the heating element and
the production of toxic gases. In addition, the high temperatures will
damage the solvent to the extent that the reaction can result in an acid
degreaser with the consequent danger of fire and injury to personnel.
Internal distillation.
When permitted by production schedules, the degreaser itself can be used
to reclaim solvent on a batch basis. Distillation is accomplished by boiling
the sump, and the distillate is collected in a separate receiver.
Liquid levels must be monitored when using the degreaser as a still to
avoid exposure of the heating element and consequent overheating of the
element. The liquid level must be kept at least 1.5" above the heating
element.
If solvent vapors are still present when this level is reached, the remaining
concentrate may be removed to a drum and added during the next cleanout
period. Fines, chips, and sludge should be removed with a hoe or similar
tool and disposed of in compliance with regulations.
Warning !
Fire Hazard
As the liquid becomes concentrated during distillation, afire hazard exists
in electrically and gas-heated degreasers if the temperature of the oil
contaminants reaches its flashpoint. To avoid this, bottom thermostats
should be set to the proper temperature for the solvent used, and should
be tested frequently. Thermostats on gas and electric degreasers should
be set to shut off at 195° F (91° C) for TCE and 260° (127° C) for perc.
Caution !
Do not inject steam into the boiling chamber, as excessive water may cause
equipment damage. Vapor thermostat setting should be 160° F (71°C) for
TCE and 180° F (82° C) for perc.
External Distillation
An external solvent recovery still combines a heat source to vaporize
the contaminated solvent, a condenser and a water separator. The unit
should be equipped with the same safety and operating controls as the
degreaser, and similar operating practices should be followed.
A separate solvent recovery still offers a number of cost-saving advantages.
The degreaser can operate for extended periods without shutdown for cleanout.
Degreasing efficiency is enhanced because the solvent is maintained relatively
free of contaminants. Operating temperatures generally are lower because
of less contamination, which reduces energy requirements. In addition,
the external still offers a higher rate of solvent recovery than is obtainable
with distillation in the degreaser.
A solvent recovery still may be connected directly to a large degreaser,
or operate independently as a free-standing unit processing solvent in
batches that are collected from a number of degreasers.
Where the still is connected to a single degreaser,
it operates continuously. The unit receives solvent from the most heavily
contaminated section of the degreaser, and returns distillate to the degreaser
rinse compartment or to a storage reservoir. Solvent level in the still
is maintained by an automatic level control switch which actuates a transfer
pump.
Solvent contaminants are accumulated in the still and periodically it
is necessary to shut down the unit for concentration and disposal of the
soils. Concentration will recover a substantial portion of the solvent
contained in the sludge. Additional solvent can be recovered by steam
sweeping, which is the injection of live steam into the boiling chamber
above the solvent toward the end of distillation. The steam forms a lower-boiling
azeotrope with TCE and perc which allows maximum solvent recovery.
Caution!
Do not use steam sweeping with 1,1,1-trichloroethane. This may cause a
hydrolytic reaction which will result in solvent breakdown, formation
of corrosive acids, and lead to equipment damage.
Warning!
Fire/Toxic Gas Hazards Residue concentrations may present a fire hazard,
or danger from toxic gases, or both. They must be handled and disposed
of in accordance % with proper safety procedures to avoid fire or toxicity
hazards to personnel.
Residue concentrations for degreaser sumps or external stills should be
handled and disposed of in accordance with local and state regulations
concerning hazardous wastes. Handling and removal should follow established
safety procedures. Residues should be cooled to room temperature; if removed
while hot, ventilation should be adequate to minimize atmospheric contamination
and resultant toxicity hazards.
For additional information, refer to Disposal of Solid Wastes, in the
following section Cleaning the Degreaser.
Operation of an External Still
Basic procedure for startup and operation of an external still is similar
to that for a degreaser, following these steps:
- Open the valve to supply condensing water
or turn on refrigerated unit's main switch.
- Check settings of control devices, then
actuate. Set thermostat settings for chlorinated solvents.
- Close drain valve.
- Fill still with solvent to operating level.
- Check water flow through condenser, and
cooling water temperature which should be at 90°-120° F (32°-49°C) at
the discharge point.
- Concentration of contaminants will raise
the boiling point of the solvent.
- When solvent temperatures approach the level
of the still sump thermostat settings for the solvent being distilled,
distillation normally will end.
- For TCE and perc only, initiate steam sweeping
by closing the steam coil inlet valve and slowly opening the steam injector
valve. Be careful to avoid foaming of the concentrated material. Optimum
solvent recovery is achieved when the flow of distillate ceases. Close
steam injector valve.
- Shut off heat supply.
- Deactivate control devices.
- Cool residue, and dispose of in accordance
with applicable environmental regulations. (See Disposal of solvent
wastes)
Degreaser Maintenance and Cleaning
Degreaser maintenance includes both regularly scheduled procedures to keep
the degreaser at optimum operating efficiency, and the periodic major cleanouts
required to maintain contamination at an acceptable level.
Routine Maintenance
A good routine maintenance program anticipates problems and helps to prevent
major work stoppages. Routine maintenance is basically good housekeeping,
and pays dividends in reduced solvent losses and faster, more effective
cleaning.
Warning
Fire/Explosion Hazard Excessive amounts of aluminum or zinc chips or fines
can, under certain circumstances, cause a violent chemical reaction which
may further result in ignition of the oils in the degreaser sump. Nearby
personnel would be subject to injury from either or both occurrences. To
prevent this, fines and chips should be removed daily.
Some recommended procedures follow. Most of these should be performed
daily; checking of temperatures, liquid flows, and steam pressure (where
used) even more frequently.
- Insure that all compartments of the equipment are maintained at proper
operating levels.
- Clean liquid-level sight glasses and porthole glasses.
- Check solvent pumps, gasketed closures, transfer lines, and other
connections for leaks.
- If steam is used for heat input, check steam pressure and steam traps.
- Check sump temperature to determine contamination level.
- When starting up for the day, check the time required for the vapor
level to rise to the midpoint of the condenser coils and hold steady.
As work is introduced, observe whether the vapor zone maintains its
level or drops substantially. Excessive heating time or vapor level
drop may indicate need for degreaser cleanout.
- Check condensate trough.
- Check solvent flow from the water separator back to the degreaser.
Reduced flow may indicate not only a blockage but also diminished vapor
generation.
- Check water drain on water separator.
- Check temperature of condenser coolant (water cooled units) at exit
point; maintain between 90° and 120° F (32°-49°C)
- Since solvent vapors remove lubricant from conveyors, lubricate
frequently.
Cleaning the Degreaser
Periodically, thorough cleaning of the degreaser is essential to maintain
safe working climate and to realize both maximum vapor degreasing effectiveness
and economy. The operation must be carried out by personnel adequately
trained in cleanout practice, the toxicology and handling of chlorinated
solvents, and the proper use of protective equipment. A written procedure
must be established and adhered to, which should include work orders detailing
all preparatory and cleanout steps to be taken, and safety precautions
to be followed.
External Preparation and Cleaning
With many open-top degreasers, it may be possible to remove dirt, sludge,
and metal chips from outside of the degreaser, following these recommended
procedures. For larger equipment, the following steps are to be taken
prior to entering the degreaser:
- Remove solvent from degreaser, or distill as much solvent as possible
observing the recommended 1.5" minimum liquid level above heating
elements.
- Turn off heat supply and allow degreaser to cool. Keep water flowing
or refrigeration operating.
- When sump cools, turn off water supply.
- Drain residues. If still warm, provide additional ventilation.
- Ventilate equipment thoroughly to remove residual solvent as completely
as possible.
- Carefully remove thermometers and safety devices to avoid damage to
them during cleanout.
- Disconnect heat-supply -line fittings.
- Disconnect solvent lines leading to degreaser and water separator.
- Remove cleanout ports and heating elements.
- Lock off all power to pumps and conveyors.
- Remove dirt, sludge, and metal chips from the bottom of each compartment
as thoroughly as possible without entering the equipment.
- At this point, if it is necessary to enter the degreaser, the
following safety procedures must be observed.
Warning
Exposure to high concentrations of solvent vapor may result in unconsciousness
or death. Personnel must not enter an atmosphere with a high concentration
of solvent vapors unless safe entry procedures are followed, including
the use of self-contained breathing apparatus together with backup personnel
Safety procedures for entering a degreaser
The following procedures must be observed when it is necessary to enter
the degreaser:
- The entire system must be drained.
- All access ports must be removed or locked in an open position.
- All solvent vapors must be expelled.
- Purge the degreaser with forced air directed toward the bottom
of each compartment.
- Using proper instrumentation, measure the air quality inside
the degreaser.
- The person entering the degreaser must wear a harness and
lifeline and NIOSH/ MSHA-approved self-contained breathing apparatus
of a pressure-demand type with full facepiece
- A second person should hold the free end of the lifeline,
must be similarly equipped for degreaser entry, and must be able to
communicate at all times with the first person when the first person
is inside the degreaser.
- A third person must be within audible hailing distance. The
second person should not enter the degreaser unless absolutely necessary
to remove the first person, and must not enter before the third person
has been alerted. The third person must not enter the degreaser.
Internal cleaning procedures
- Brush out the condensate trough and check to make certain
that there are no obstructions to condensate
flow.
- Brush cooling coils, walls, and compartment floors to remove
accumulated rust and scale. Take care to avoid damaging corrosion-resistant
finishes.
- Brush down rusted areas; inspect and lubricate conveyor system
or internal drive mechanism as required.
- Scrape and brush heating elements free of all caked sludge
to assure efficient heat transfer. Further equipment cleanout should
include:
- Clean out condensate lines from the collection trough outlet
to the water separator, and from the water
separator to the discharge point in the degreaser.
- Clean out the water separator and remove any sludge that
may have accumulated in the bottom.
- Clean strainers, filters, sight glasses, and porthole glasses
before reassembly.
- Clean and check controls, indicators and regulators before
reassembly. Adjust if necessary.
- While unit is down, it may be a good time to perform other
maintenance, including a check of doors, pipe fittings, gauges, and
other trouble spots for leaks. Solvent-resistant gaskets and sealing
compounds should be used to help prevent solvent loss.
- Reconnect heat input.
- If manual cleanout is insufficient, the degreaser may be
cleaned with a hot solution of soda ash and water.
Fill the unit with water to a level about 4 to 6 inches above the
heating element, and add one pound of soda
ash per five gallons of water in the degreaser. Heat this solution
for one-half hour. The sides and all
compartments should be thoroughly washed, after which the unit should
be drained, rinsed well, and dried.
- Turn on water supply to condensers and beat exchangers and
inspect for water leaks. Repair any leaks.
- Fill all compartments to normal levels with solvent, and
start the degreaser.
Treating an acid degreaser
Treatment of an acid degreaser consists of neutralizing the acid solvent,
draining the degreaser, cleaning the unit manually, and neutralizing
with a heated soda ash solution.
Warning !
Fire/Explosion Hazard An acid degreaser presents the potential of fire
and explosion with consequent personal injury. A continuing acid reaction
results in the formation of toxic gases including hydrogen chloride,
and possible violent exothermic reaction with iron oxides and aluminum
when present in the sump. The acid degreaser should be neutralized immediately,
following recommended procedures.
The following steps should be employed:
- Turn off heat.
- Add soda ash to sump in a solution of one pound of soda ash
to 5 gallons of water, and agitate as much as possible while solvent
is cooling.
- When solvent is cool, remove from degreaser.
- Following the procedure outlined in the previous section,
remove as much sludge as possible from outside of the degreaser.
- If it is necessary to enter the degreaser, the safety precautions
outlined in the previous section must be observed.
- Fill the degreaser with water to a depth of 4-6 inches above
the heating elements, and add soda ash at the rate of one pound per
5 gallons of water in the sump.
- Heat the soda ash solution and boil if possible. Wash all
parts of the degreaser that were in contact with the acid solvent.
- Drain degreaser and dry completely.
- Add fresh solvent.
- Determine cause of acid generation and take action to prevent
future occurrence.
Disposal of Solvent Wastes
Sludge from a VD or from a solvent still may be stored in drums until
ready for disposal. Drums should not be tightly sealed, especially those
that contain sludge with aluminum residues. Prior to disposal, drums
should be stored outdoors and away from any combustible materials or
source of combustion. Solvent wastes normally consist of chlorinated
solvent, oil, tar, metal particles, buffing compounds, and other contaminants.
Chlorinated solvents are considered hazardous wastes under the Resource
Conservation and Recovery Act. Therefore any waste containing chlorinated
solvents must be disposed of by approved incineration. Before disposing
of wastes containing chlorinated solvents, every effort should be made
to recover as much of the solvent as possible by distillation. A solvent
recycling firm should be considered. It is the responsibility of the
generator of any waste to ensure that disposal is carried out in accordance
with the Clean Air Act, Clean Water Act, the Resource Conservation and
Recovery Act, and all relevant state or local laws and regulations regarding
disposal.
Warning !
Do not add dry soda ash to an acid degreaser. This may cause flashing
from the degreaser, and consequent injury as nearby personnel are exposed
to the eruption of hot solvent and corrosive acid. Soda ash must always
be added in a water solution.
Warning !
Do not add soda ash solution to boiling solvent or to solvent that is
above the azeotropic temperature of 149' F (65' Q. This may cause flashing
from the degreaser, with a consequent eruption of hot solvent. Allow
solvent to cool, or carefully dilute with water to reduce temperature.
Warning !
Explosion Hazard
Do not add sodium hydroxide (NaOH) or other strong alkalies to an acid
degreaser This can result in a violent chemical reaction and there is
even the possibility of an explosion, with consequent danger of injury
or death to nearby personnel. Use only a soda ash or sodium bicarbonate
solution.
Corrective Action
Water separator: Insure that separator is clean and that water flow
through separator is unhindered.
Condensing coil: Check temperature of discharge water. It should range
between 90° and 120° F (32°-49° C) to avoid condensing atmospheric moisture.
Water on incoming work: Determine whether parts entering degreaser are
wet or carrying water-based cutting, oils.
Collection trough: Check installation and performance.
Freeboard chiller: Freeboard refrigerated chillers should have separate
collection trough and water separator.
Poor Cleaning Action
Ineffective cleaning of the work generally is a result of insufficient
contact with the solvent and/or solvent vapor. Following are some common
contributory conditions:
Cause: Vapor immersion and/or rinse cycle too short.
Correction: Leave work in vapor zone until all condensation stops.
Cause: Vapor level too low for adequate cleaning; and rinse.
Correction: Check heat input to insure sufficient vapor generation.
Cause: Vapor level collapse because of too heavy a load. If temperature
of work increases, oils may bake on parts.
Correction: Follow degreaser equipment manufacturer's guidelines on
loading.
Low Acid Acceptance
Solvent stabilizers are effective in the industry in resisting acid
formation and solvent decomposition, even after repeated distillation.
However the original acid acceptance of solvents will gradually decline,
depending on production volume and the type of work being cleaned. Periodic
addition of make-up solvent restores acid acceptance.
Occasionally a degreaser becomes acid, creating a situation that requires
immediate action and which could result in a safety hazard.
Troubleshooting Vapor Degreaser
High solvent consumption -excessive vapor odors
These problems usually are related: excessive vapor odor is an indication
of vapor loss to the atmosphere. If the cause of pronounced vapor odors
is located and corrected, solvent consumption will be reduced. A detection
meter will help locate the source of vapor loss.
Cause: Solvent dragout.
Correction: Rack parts for complete drainage; eliminate pockets and
recesses.
Cause: Vapor level too high.
Correction: Check vapor thermostat and sump temperature; check and adjust
heat input to maintain vapor level at midpoint of condenser coils. (Refer
to recommended vapor thermostat and sump temperature.)
Cause: Entry and removal; rates too fast.
Correction: Entry and exit rates should not exceed 11 ft/minute. Faster
speeds pull vapors out of degreaser.
Cause: Insufficient clearance between basket and degreaser walls; causes
piston effect as work is lowered and raised.
Correction: Work should not exceed 50 % of degreaser surface area.
Cause: Solvent loss from spraying,
Correction: Keep nozzle at least 6 inches below vapor level; use only
enough pressure to wash the work.
Cause: Drafts which sweep vapor from degreaser.
Correction: Avoid open doors and windows; shield degreaser from other
drafts such as exhausts.
Cause: Solvent evaporation from open tank.
Correction: Cover degreaser when idle or shut down. Cover water separator
if open-tank construction.
Cause: Leaks.
Correction: Locate source with detection equipment. Check valve packing
nuts, pump packing, sight glasses, piping, and gaskets.
Cause: Insufficient freeboard height allows vapors to escape to atmosphere.
Correction: Freeboard height should be at least 100 percent of tank
width.
Cause: Insufficient condensation.
Correction: Insure that water is flowing through cooling coils before
turning on heat input
to sump; confirm that water temperature at condenser outlet is between
90°-120° F
(32°-49°C).
Cause: Vapor level collapse. Too heavy a load will cause vapor collapse,
creating
air-vapor mixture that is pushed out of degreaser.
Correction: Check equipment rating; do not overload degreaser.
Cause: Insufficient cycle time; work emerges dirty and wet, carrying
solvent into
atmosphere.
Correction: Wait until all condensation stops before removing work from
degreaser.
Cause: Absorbent materials.
Correction: Do not use degreaser to clean clothing or leather goods;
do not use wood or other absorbent materials in baskets.
Cause: Excessive moisture. Water in sump forms azeotrope with TCE and
perc which has a lower boiling point than solvent, causing vapor loss
to
atmosphere.
Correction: See following section on moisture contamination.
Moisture Contamination
Excessive moisture in the solvent can cause spotting and corrosion of
the work as well as damage to the equipment.
Caution
In the presence of excess water, 1,1,1-trichloroethane (EPA restricted
along with Freon) is subject to a hydrolytic reaction that results in
solvent decomposition and the formation of acidic material. This is
highly corrosive and may cause equipment damage. The degreasing operation
should be continually monitored for signs of excessive moisture.
Indications of water contamination
Following are some indications of excessive moisture and the corrective
action to be taken.
Water spots, equipment rust: Excessive water in the solvent will spot
or corrode the work; rust will develop on degreaser walls around cooling
coils and condensate trough.
Ghosting: A dense white cloud develops in the vapor zone. Density increases
with water concentration.
- 30 -
Bibliography
"The Design, Operation & Maintenance of a Detrex Degreaser"
Detrex Chemical , Detroit, MI 1952
"Vapor Degreasing" PPG Industries, Pittsburgh, PA 1986
" The ABC's of Vapor Degreaser Conversion" Ibid 1985
"Vapor Degreasing with Freon TF Solvent" Dupont, Wilmington,
DE 1983
":Solvent Emission Reduction" Ibid 1988
|